Map Rating Thread

Does what it says on the tin.

This is a topic for posting your maps, and rating the maps of others.
When posting a rating, you should try to do the following:
- Be honest when it comes to rating
- Any flaws you can see should be outlined
- Make sure all criticism is constructive
- Be polite
- Suggest Further improvement, so People can improve their mapping skills.

When Posting a Map, make sure:
- You credit all tiles/palletes you have used, if they are not your own
- Submit your map in the format below
Hack Name:
Map Name:
Rom Base:
Credits:
- Use Spoiler Tags around images.
- Explain features of your map where necessary.


I'll Start us off
Hack Name: Pokémon Lumaria
Map Name: Pokémon Academy
Rom Base: Pokémon Firered
Credits:
- Kyledove (OW's, tiles (wooden houses))
- Pey(Tree tile, sign)
- Alistar (Don Patch) (Tiles and pallet)
- Mitchel1 (Rombase)

Spoiler:

Y is every one making hacks

Akera.. wrote:

Does what it says on the tin.

This is a topic for posting your maps, and rating the maps of others.
When posting a rating, you should try to do the following:
- Be honest when it comes to rating
- Any flaws you can see should be outlined
- Make sure all criticism is constructive
- Be polite
- Suggest Further improvement, so People can improve their mapping skills.

When Posting a Map, make sure:
- You credit all tiles/palletes you have used, if they are not your own
- Submit your map in the format below
Hack Name:
Map Name:
Rom Base:
Credits:
- Use Spoiler Tags around images.
- Explain features of your map where necessary.


I'll Start us off
Hack Name: Pokémon Lumaria
Map Name: Pokémon Academy
Rom Base: Pokémon Firered
Credits:
- Kyledove (OW's, tiles (wooden houses))
- Pey(Tree tile, sign)
- Alistar (Don Patch) (Tiles and pallet)
- Mitchel1 (Rombase)

Spoiler:

This looks nice, I always like the idea of a Pokemon Academy! Anyway, one thing I would change are the cabins (or dorms) You should make all the doors on the same side and the same color (I noticed some where red and others where Brown)
Also, I think the Mountain Pallette is just a little too bright. Other than that this Map looks awesome! 4.8/5

SuperrStaraptor wrote:

Y is every one making hacks

I started it, Munch was doing one already and when Steel made this section everyone copied off us

[quote="Akera.."]
I'll Start us off
Hack Name: Pokémon Lumaria
Map Name: Pokémon Academy
Rom Base: Pokémon Firered
Credits:
- Kyledove (OW's, tiles (wooden houses))
- Pey(Tree tile, sign)
- Alistar (Don Patch) (Tiles and pallet)
- Mitchel1 (Rombase)

I like it, I would do what munching orange said about the doors and I would make the the lower middle building not so long (up and down wise). the roof is too jarring. also if the stairs to the cliffs in the back don't serve a specific purpose I would take them out.